Key Lime Pie with Chocolate Nut Crust

You don’t have to travel to Key West to enjoy a taste of the island life. Our Key Lime Pie recipe features a refreshing filling that melts in your mouth and an AMERICAN HERITAGE® Chocolate crust.

Like many desserts, the exact origin of the Key Lime Pie is a bit of a mystery. However, the first record of Key Lime Pie comes from the tropical island of Key West. A cook known simply as Aunt Sally made a Key Lime Pie for Florida’s first self-made millionaire, William Curry. It has been rumored that she used a recipe for lemon icebox pie but swapped the lemons for limes!

Read Recipe