Our Favorite Pies for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving may look a little different this year, but that doesn’t mean that we can’t bake up some delicious memories! Here is a roundup of our favorite Thanksgiving pie recipes for this holiday season.


AMERICAN HERITAGE® Chocolate Pumpkin Pie

a close up photo of chocolate pumpkin pie with decorative crust

When the holidays roll around we all start hunting out spice for everything nice, and nothing goes better in a pie than pumpkin and chocolate. Match made in heaven!

Get the Recipe


Chocolate Cream Pie

A close up photo of chocolate cream pie with a slice missing

This chocolate cream pie features a perfectly flaky cream cheese crust and a creamy, decadent filling that’s perfect for your Thanksgiving table!

Get the Recipe


Chocolate & Tahini Icebox Pie

A slice of chocolate tahini pie on a white plate

If you’re looking for the perfect make-ahead, no-bake pie, look no further! This icebox pie is easy to make and packed full of flavor.

Get the Recipe


Chocolate and Custard Pear Tart

a slice of chocolate custard pear tart on a green plate

Ok, so not technically a pie, but this tart recipe features a buttery cookie-like pastry crust that is filled with AMERICAN HERITAGE Chocolate, tender pears, and a creamy custard. Everyone will be asking for seconds!

Get the Recipe